Entries by Posted by Linda Rink (62)


Don’t Delude Yourself: The Ukraine Crisis Is Far From Over

MONDAY, JUNE 16, 2014

Posted by: JUDY DEMPSEY.  Dempsey is a nonresident senior associate at Carnegie Europe and editor in chief of Strategic Europe. 

Ukraine is deteriorating, and quickly. The brief honeymoon that followed Petro Poroshenko’s inauguration as president is over. It is time for the West to step up its actions.

The past few days have seen a dangerous escalation of the crisis. On June 14, pro-Russian fighters shot down a Ukrainian military transport jet as it was trying to land at Luhansk airport in Eastern Ukraine. The Ukrainian prosecutor’s office said all 49 people on board—40 paratroopers and nine crew members—had died.

NATO provided satellite imagery showing Russian tanks and heavy artillery crossing the border into Ukraine. The deliveries, shown in three sets of images dated May 30, June 6, and June 11, also included rocket launchers, according to the U.S. State Department.

Angela Merkel, the German chancellor, and François Hollande, the French president, spoke to Russian President Vladimir Putin on June 14 asking him to control better Russia’s borders with Ukraine. But so far, every one of Merkel’s attempts to persuade Putin to stop Russia’s support for militia groups in Eastern Ukraine has failed.

Russia continues to deny it is arming rebels in the East of Ukraine. Instead, Putin has called on the Ukrainian government to stop its military operations. Yet Kiev is simply attempting to regain control of its territory while also trying to establish some dialogue with Moscow to end the crisis.

In this situation, doing nothing is not an option for Europe or America. The longer European governments hesitate, the more Ukraine is threatened by civil war. Its citizens will flee the conflict, and the growing humanitarian crisis in the East of the country will increase.

There may also be spillover into other parts of Eastern Europe. Just consider the political instability in Moldova and Russia’s meddling in Transnistria, not to speak of the lingering conflict between Armenia and Azerbaijan over the territory of Nagorno-Karabakh.

European leaders cannot afford to believe that the Ukraine crisis will just fade away. It won’t. Nor will they be able to contain it unless they act. Given Russia’s continued meddling, Merkel needs to push the EU to impose a third round of sanctions.

It is true that the first two rounds of sanctions have had only an indirect impact on the Russian economy, while Putin’s popularity continues at an all-time high. But that should not deter the EU and the United States from pressing ahead with targeted sanctions that would include a visa ban for Putin’s inner circle combined with the freezing of their assets and a comprehensive ban on arms exports.

NATO can’t stand idly by, either. The measures U.S. President Barack Obama announced in Warsaw on June 5 go some way toward reassuring NATO’s Eastern allies. Yes, it is important that NATO conducts training and sends troops on a rotational basis to Poland, the Baltic states, and Romania. But is that really enough to deter Russia? Poland and Estonia both want permanent NATO bases on their territories. Such a presence could have an immense psychological impact for the region—and for Russia.

There are other tough decisions that NATO will have to make at its summit in South Wales in September. Georgia wants to be granted a NATO Membership Action Plan, a program of advice and practical support that would set the country on an unambiguous path toward membership.

Several European countries oppose giving the Membership Action Plan to Georgia, not only because they argue it would provoke Russia but also because they doubt that NATO would be prepared to defend Georgia in case of an armed conflict. So what takes precedence: meeting NATO’s criteria, or pandering to Russia?

NATO and the EU also have to decide how to deal with Moldova. Together with Georgia, Moldova wants to sign a political and economic association agreement with the EU. Russia is keen to stop that from happening. The reason isn’t just that Chişinău, despite all its systemic weaknesses, and Tbilisi would move economically closer to Europe. The impact these accords would have on strengthening civil society and democratic values cannot be underestimated, as the Kremlin now understands, and fears.

That is why the Kremlin has also embarked on an anti-EU and anti-NATO campaign further afield, in Montenegro, a small Western Balkan country that wants to join both Western organizations. Despite a pervasive culture of corruption, Prime Minister Milo Đukanović is hoping that Montenegro will become the 29th member of NATO at the alliance’s September summit.

Don’t bet on it. Montenegro is vulnerable to pressure from Moscow. Russians own about 40 percent of the republic’s Adriatic coast. Up to 7,000 permanent Russian residents have taken advantage of the country’s lax rule of law, while Russian businesses have heavily invested in the republic, not always to Montenegro’s advantage.

It is precisely to break this Russian stranglehold that part of the Montenegrin political class now wants to wed the country to the Euro-Atlantic organizations. But analysts in the region say that Russian propaganda in the Western Balkans has been stepped up over the past year to prevent that from happening.

In this situation, Western governments need to understand that their neighborhood is being drawn into Moscow’s power games and the Ukraine crisis. That is why further sanctions against Putin, the establishment of permanent bases in Eastern European NATO countries, and unstinting support for civil society and democratic institutions throughout Eastern Europe is crucial. The competition about values has only begun.


G-7 Leaders Statement on Ukraine - 4/26/14

Office of the Press Secretary
April 26, 2014
We, the leaders of Canada, France, Germany, Italy, Japan, the United Kingdom, the United States, the President of the European Council and the President of the European Commission, join in expressing our deep concern at the continued efforts by separatists backed by Russia to destabilize eastern Ukraine and our commitment to taking further steps to ensure a peaceful and stable environment for the May 25 presidential election.

We welcomed the positive steps taken by Ukraine to meet its commitments under the Geneva accord of April 17 by Ukraine, Russia, the European Union, and the United States. These actions include working towards constitutional reform and decentralization, proposing an amnesty law for those who will peacefully leave the buildings they have seized in eastern Ukraine, and supporting the work of the Organization for Security and Cooperation in Europe (OSCE).  We also note that the Government of Ukraine has acted with restraint in dealing with the armed bands illegally occupying government buildings and forming illegal checkpoints.

In contrast, Russia has taken no concrete actions in support of the Geneva accord.  It has not publicly supported the accord, nor condemned the acts of pro-separatists seeking to destabilize Ukraine, nor called on armed militants to leave peacefully the government buildings they've occupied and put down their arms.  Instead, it has continued to escalate tensions by increasingly concerning rhetoric and ongoing threatening military maneuvers on Ukraine's border.

We reiterate our strong condemnation of Russia's illegal attempt to annex Crimea and Sevastopol, which we do not recognize.  We will now follow through on the full legal and practical consequences of this illegal annexation, including but not limited to the economic, trade and financial areas.
We have now agreed that we will move swiftly to impose additional sanctions on Russia.  Given the urgency of securing the opportunity for a successful and peaceful democratic vote next month in Ukraine's presidential elections, we have committed to act urgently to intensify targeted sanctions and measures to increase the costs of Russia's actions. 

Russia's actions in Ukraine and the response from the international community already have imposed significant costs on its economy.  While we continue to prepare to move to broader, coordinated sanctions, including sectoral measures should circumstances warrant, as we committed to in The Hague on March 24, we underscore that the door remains open to a diplomatic resolution of this crisis, on the basis of the Geneva accord.  We urge Russia to join us in committing to that path.

JBANC delivers Ukraine support letters to all Senate offices

Washington, DC) – On April 14th JBANC delivered letters to all U.S. Senate offices to thank for support for Ukraine and also to urge for further steps to stop Russian aggression and deal with security issues in Ukraine and its Central and East European neighbors. 

Read full letter text below: 

April 14, 2014 
The Honorable .... 
United States Senate 
Washington, D.C. 20510 

Dear Senator .....: 

The Joint Baltic American National Committee, Inc. (JBANC), representing Americans of Estonian, Latvian, and Lithuanian heritage, has worked with Congress since 1961 to raise issues of interest and concern to the Baltic-American community, and to help formulate U.S. policy affecting the Baltic nations. 

Thank you for your support in passing H.R. 4152, the Support of the Sovereignty, Integrity, Democracy, and Economic Stability of Ukraine Act of 2014” (Public Law: 113-95), and S. 2183, “United States International Programming to Ukraine and Neighboring Regions” (PL: 113-96). Both were signed into law by President Obama on April 3. It is a start for assisting Ukraine in its time of need against the forces of Putin’s aggression. There is, however, much more work to be done, particularly now with Crimea completely occupied and Eastern Ukraine under assault, and worries in neighboring countries increasing daily. 

We encourage the swift implementation of these laws, and note Section 7 of PL: 113-95, dealing with appropriations for security cooperation and defense assistance to Ukraine and CEE countries, and directing the President to: 

(1) enhance security cooperation efforts and relationships amongst countries in Central and Eastern Europe and among the United States, the EU, and countries in Central and Eastern Europe; (2) provide additional security assistance, including defense articles, services, and military training, to countries in Central and Eastern Europe, including Ukraine; and (3) support reform and capacity-building efforts within the military, intelligence, and security services in Central and Eastern Europe, including Ukraine. 
In continuing to monitor the actions of Putin’s regime, we look for further support in identifying those in his government culpable of repressions and human rights violations and urge a significant expansion of the Magnitsky sanctions list, to both shine a light on serious abuses and to hold perpetrators accountable for their actions. 

Putin’s brazen tactics remind us of Hitler’s Anschluss, and Stalin’s campaign against the Baltics in 1939-40. This sets a dangerous precedent of undermining the sanctity of borders. Moscow has done this before, in its 2008 takeover of Georgian territory and continuing occupation of Abkhazia and South Ossetia. The growing legacy of Moscow’s meddling in the internal affairs of other countries demonstrates Putin’s vision about how Ukraine should be structured to suit Russia’s economic interests. It is a spectacle of direct instigation by the Kremlin, or at least one perpetuated by henchmen implanted there by Moscow for the purpose of fomenting unrest. 

The consequences affect us all. We look forward to working together on these critical issues of national security. 

Karl Altau 
Managing Director , Joint Baltic American National Committee

CEEC Statement on Ukraine - April 17, 2014

The EANC, as a member of the CEEC, played a major role in the development of the following statement and call to action.  Please contact the Administration and your Senators and Representatives and voice support of the action items listed.

The President 
Comments: 202-456-1111
Switchboard: 202-456-1414




The Central and East European Coalition (CEEC) joins the United States government in condemning Russia’s aggression against Ukraine and its illegal annexation of Crimea.  The CEEC, comprised of 18 national organizations representing more than 20 million Americans of Central and Eastern Europe heritage, fully supports Ukraine’s aspirations for a democratic society living in peace and security with its neighbors. 
To date, the sanctions imposed by the United States have been insufficient to stop Russia’s further aggression into Ukraine.  Indeed, it appears that the security and stability of the entire Central and East European region is at stake unless further immediate action is taken by the United States, NATO, and the European Union. 
The CEEC therefore calls upon the United States government to do, and work with its allies to implement, the following:
  •   Support a major OSCE and UN peacekeeping mission (both civilian and military) to Eastern and Southern Ukraine to monitor the situation on the ground and deter provocations that may lead to Russian military intervention;
  •         Share relevant intelligence with the Ukrainian government in real time;
  •         Hold immediate joint NATO exercises in Ukraine and in bordering NATO ally countries such as Poland and the Baltic states;
  •         Support the establishment of permanent NATO bases in these front-line countries to assure their security.  Bases currently used by NATO for training and supply purposes in Central Europe should be made permanent and re-focused to territorial defense;
  •         Direct U.S. Navy ships to accept friendly invitations to visit Ukrainian ports;
  •         Provide Ukraine with Major Non-NATO Ally Status, thus conferring a variety of military and financial advantages and privileges that are otherwise not available to non-NATO countries, including the delivery of vital weapons;
  •         Extend immediate NATO Membership Action Plan (MAP) to Georgia and other countries in the region to solidify Euro-Atlantic structures;
  •         Increase U.S. assistance to Georgia, Armenia, Moldova, and Belarus to maintain their independence;
  •         Provide assistance to Ukraine to facilitate its continuing transition to a democratic and tolerant society that fully respects fundamental freedoms and the rights of all minority communities, the latter thereby also dispelling a pretext for Russian aggression;
  •         Support Ukraine’s full integration into Western structures by accelerating Ukraine’s accession into NATO and the European Union;
  •         Take action on President Obama’s Executive Order expanding economic sanctions on Russia to include not only individuals within Putin’s inner circle, but major sectors of Russia’s economy; provide assistance to minimize the impact of economic sanctions on countries bordering Russia; work with major  U.S. companies to curtail their business dealings with Russia;
  •         Follow through to provide increased funding authorized by the Ukraine Support Act, signed by President Obama into law on April 3, for Radio Free Europe/Radio Liberty and the Voice of America to expand their broadcasting in Russian, Ukrainian, and Tatar;
  •         Increase funding for people to people programs with Russia and its neighboring countries in both student and professional sectors;
  •         Bolster U.S. financial support for Ukraine by supporting a 21st century Marshall Plan aimed at stabilizing and strengthening trans-Atlantic and regional security.
 By implementing the above recommendations, we will build on the laudable steps already taken by President Obama and help ensure the safety and security of not only Ukraine, but the entire Central and East European regions.


EANC and JBANC Events and Activities in Response to Russia’s Annexation of Crimea

3/24/14 Update from Marju Rink-Abel, EANC President:

EANC and JBANC are members of the Central and East European Coalition (CEEC), and are working with that organization regarding the security of the whole region.  We will not be effective nor will be we heard if we focus only on Estonia or the Baltics.

The priority right now is on Ukraine, and getting the Senate to pass S.2124 - Support for the Sovereignty, Integrity, Democracy and Economic Stability of Ukraine – which will provide Ukraine with a billion dollar loan guarantee.  Ukraine needs to be shored up immediately, which will help with the security of NATO countries as well.  It would not be productive to divert or divide our efforts in order to focus on a Congressional resolution regarding support for the Baltics alone, especially since both individual members of Congress and the Administration have already voiced their support, and taken some concrete actions.  

For instance, the U.S. has sent additional fighter planes to Lithuania to assist in patrolling Baltic air space.  Vice President Joe Biden went to Lithuania on March 18 to reassure Baltic leaders that the U.S. is committed to defending its NATO allies in the face of Russia's intervention in Crimea. Biden said that the U.S. commitment to defending allies under the NATO treaty is, in his words, "ironclad."  While earlier in Poland, Biden met with Poland’s president and President Ilves of Estonia. 

The following events have taken place in Washington:

1.  Demonstrations
In addition to the demonstration on March 6 organized by the Ukrainians, JBANC organized a rally for Ukraine on March 2 in Washington.  JBANC and EANC representatives were present at both and Marju Rink-Abel spoke at both in the name of Estonian Americans.  Photos are on the EANC webpage.  The following press release about these events is on JBANC’s webpage:

(Washington, DC) – Members of the Joint Baltic American Committee, Inc. (JBANC) and other Baltic-Americans engaged actively in rallies in Washington, DC over the last week to lend support to Ukraine against Russia’s aggression. 

On March 6, a mass rally in front of the White House brought dozens of activists from the Baltic-American community to an estimated crowd of more than 2000 people from throughout the United States. The rally was organized in solidarity with Ukraine, and to denounce Putin’s aggression in Crimea, which is in violation of Ukraine’s territorial integrity and international laws. Moscow’s actions are being strongly denounced, and JBANC is sharing in the global condemnation. 

Messages of support for Ukraine were given by Members of Congress, including House Baltic Caucus members Representatives Marcy Kaptur of Ohio, Bill Pascrell of New Jersey, and Sander Levin of Michigan. Members of the Baltic-American community also gave remarks at the rally – JBANC Board member Marju Rink-Abel, President of the Estonian American National Council, Ausma Tomsevics of the American Latvian Association, and Asta Banionis of the Lithuanian American Community. 

Ms. Tomsevics, in her remarks of support for Ukraine, suggested that the United States “implement sanctions and legislation to extinguish the geopolitical control efforts of Russia, including moving forward to expedite the approval of U.S. natural gas exports [to Ukraine].” 

The United States Congress is currently considering a $1 billion economic aid package to Ukraine, which includes support for energy projects to help Ukraine fend off pressure from Moscow. 

Many other members from the Central and East European Coalition (CEEC) spoke at the rally, which was organized by the Ukrainian Congress Committee of America, JBANC’s partner in the CEEC. Among the many hundreds of other participants of the rally were many Crimean Tatars, who are not only suffering now under Russia’s aggression, but reliving memories of their en masse forced deportation by Stalin in 1944. 

Other demonstrations in support of Ukraine were held this week in Washington, DC, including a rally at Dupont Circle which was organized by JBANC and featured remarks by Ambassadors Olexsander Motsyk of Ukraine and Zygimantas Pavilionis of Lithuania, and David Kramer, president of Freedom House. Another demonstration was held later that day in front of the Russian Embassy. Other recent rallies in support of Ukraine in New York and Chicago have included many activists from the Baltic-American communities. 

2. White House conference call
JBANC was invited by the White House to participate in a conference call with senior-level administration staff to receive an update on the Obama administration's ongoing work to address the crisis in Ukraine.   During that call the importance of passing S.2124 was also discussed. 

3.  JBANC letter to Congress
JBANC, representing EANC and Latvian and Lithuanian central organizations, hand delivered the following letter to 95 Senate offices, and mailed to the other 5: 

March 11, 2014

The Honorable ------
United States Senate
Washington, D.C. 20510
Dear Senator ------
The Joint Baltic American National Committee, Inc. (JBANC), representing Americans of Estonian, Latvian, and Lithuanian heritage, has worked with Congress since 1961 to raise issues of interest and concern to the Baltic-American community, and to help formulate U.S. policy affecting the Baltic nations.
We strongly condemn the brazen actions of Putin’s government against the people of Ukraine and that country’s territorial integrity. Russia’s military invasion of Crimea and its escalation of the conflict are an affront to international civility and law and order, a threat to neighboring countries including Estonia, Latvia, and Lithuania, and a shameful display for decent citizens of Russia, who are enduring Putin’s increasing authoritarianism.  The disinformation and outright fabrications generated by the Kremlin’s propaganda machinery against Ukraine, its people, and government is outrageous and dangerous. The forceful meddling in regional political affairs in Crimea under the real imposition of force reminds us of similar tactics used by Soviet occupiers against the Baltic countries in 1939-40. This scenario repeated itself throughout Central and Eastern European lands that came under Soviet control and colonization. It was not acceptable then, and it is not acceptable today.
Putin’s aggression sets a terrible precedent. It must be stopped. We ask for your support in the following areas:
1)      Consider the Support for Ukraine Act in a timely matter, and to support energy relief for Ukraine;
2)      Co-sponsor S. 1933, the Global “Magnitsky” Human Rights Act, which would help broaden sanctions against corrupt oligarchs and human rights violators by denying them travel to the U.S. and by freezing their assets. This would include sanctions against the former Yanukovych regime. We hope that implementation of the original Magnitsky law (PL: 112-208) is also taken seriously, by having the list of individuals and sanctions expanded against Putin’s regime. We ask that the U.S. also consider other sanctions directed against the  Putin state, including suspending Russia from the G8, and blocking their OECD membership;  
3)      Support legislation (including S. 192), to export LNG from the U.S. to Strategic Allies, including the Baltics.  
These measures would all greatly demonstrate conviction by the United States, which would send a strong message for Putin, and also show support for the democratic aspirations of Ukraine.  

We look forward to your support and working together on these issues.  

Karl Altau
Managing Director
4.  Diaspora communities’ letter to Congress
EANC and JBANC are co-signers of a letter to Congress on the Ukrainian legislation.  The text is at the end of this summary of activities. *

5.  Meeting with former ambassadors to Central European region
The Central and East European Coalition (with JBANC and EANC in attendance) met last week with former Ambassadors Bill Taylor (Ukraine), Rich Kauzlarich (Azerbaijan and Bosnia-Herzegovina), and Bill Courtney (Kazakhstan and Georgia) to discuss possible actions.  
As a result, the CEEC came up with an action plan that includes holding two policy briefings on Ukraine in Congress in the next two weeks, visits to key Congressional offices, and a meeting with the Administration.

6.  Meeting with State Department
On March 25, EANC and JBANC representatives are meeting with Brent Hartley, the Deputy Assistant Secretary of State for  European and Eurasian Affairs, and Baltic Desk Officers.  The focus of the meeting is on the Baltics, Russia, and Ukraine.

7.  JBANC co-sponsors policy briefing
 A Congressional policy briefing titled Belarus: Catalyzing Positive Change in the Geographic Center of Europe, will take place on March 25, tying in events in Ukraine. It is co-sponsored by JBANC, Freedom House, and  the Belarusan-American Association, in cooperation with the U.S. Helsinki Commission. 

* Text of diaspora communities’ letter:
Dear Majority Leader Reid, Speaker Boehner, Minority Leader McConnell and Minority Leader Pelosi:
Ukraine needs your immediate help.

As the leaders of more than three dozen American ethnic organizations, representing tens of millions of voters across the United States , we call on you to provide vital support to Ukraine by immediately passing Senate Bill 2124. 

Under the Budapest Memorandum of 1994, the United States , the United Kingdom and the Russian Federation made assurances to protect Ukraine in the event its sovereignty is threatened by a foreign entity, in exchange for Ukraine voluntarily giving-up its uranium and nuclear warheads to Russia , at the time the world’s third largest arsenal.  

Now, twenty years after signing the Budapest Memorandum, Russia invaded the Crimea region of Ukraine , overthrew its government, held an illegitimate election for an illegal referendum and declared Crimea annexed from Ukraine .   The “Referendum” for Crimean separation from Ukraine was held in violation of the Ukrainian Constitution and International Law.  The ballot offered no real choice - just two versions of the same decision on session.  There was no option to vote to remain with Ukraine - which is why many ethnic Tatar, Ukrainian and Russian Crimeans boycotted the election.  Local leaders opposing the election were apprehended and free media was suppressed.  The election itself was fundamentally flawed:  many ballots were pre-marketed, in some venues the number of people allegedly casting ballots exceeded the actual population. The ballot boxes were transparent so that those conducting the balloting could readily see how people voted.  Soldiers with automatic weapons patrolled the entrance to the polling places.  In short, Russian claims to have Crimea have no legal or electoral basis.

As the world watches, the U.S. must take immediate action to follow-through on its commitment to Ukraine .  While Ukraine’s young government transitions and prepares for upcoming elections in its path toward building a healthy democracy, Ukraine needs immediate national security support including:  strong financial resources both from the United States via a $1 billion loan and IMF funding, military support and training, and increased sanctions against those individuals responsible for threatening its sovereignty, the latter of which President Obama continues to  diplomatically execute by issuing Executive Orders. 

We look to Congress for leadership in providing this vital aide to Ukraine .  We commend the House for its work to quickly pass a bill providing a $1 billion loan to Ukraine , and the Senate for incorporating that $1 billion loan in S.2124, which also includes International Monetary Fund (IMF) quota reform that will further impact the aide Ukraine receives.

We join the White House, Republican and Democratic Foreign Relations Committee Senators, several dozen former U.S. cabinet secretaries and national security leaders, and more than 200 other policy experts who have voiced their strong bipartisan support for urgent IMF quota reform included in S.2124, which directly impacts Ukraine .   In a March 10 letter to you from the Bretton Woods Committee, former cabinet secretaries and national security officials urged the importance of maintaining U.S. economic leadership in the IMF and the impact it will have in lending additional resources to Ukraine “estimating that implementation of IMF quota reform would mean Ukraine would be able to borrow 60% more in rapid IMF financing (from $1B to $1.6B) than is possible today. Coupled with the U.S. $1 billion in new loan guarantees for Ukraine currently being considered by the Congress, Ukraine would have a total of $2.6 billion in emergency resources to draw upon to stabilize its economy. This enhances the geopolitical position of Ukraine ’s government in the current crisis with Russia .”

During his visit to Washington, D.C. earlier this month, Ukraine’s acting Prime Minister Arseniy Yatsenyuk expressed the importance of Ukraine receiving IMF funding and pledged to take all necessary measures to meet the conditions required by the IMF to secure this vital resource both immediately and long-term.   His administration continues to work with the IMF daily to meet those qualifications.  As Ukraine takes its necessary steps to obtain IMF funding, we must take our necessary steps to maximize that funding.  We have seen the success stories of IMF funding, from Ireland to Poland , Jordan to Tunisia .   Support for fulfilling our commitment to the IMF is support for Ukraine ’s prosperity and peace, and therefore stability and well-being for the entire geo-political region.

Failing to follow-through on our Budapest Memorandum commitment in a timely manner risks destabilizing Ukraine and the entire geo-political structure which has maintained peace in Europe for the past 25 years, while also sending a dangerous message to the rest of the world about the folly of a country’s giving up the nuclear option.  This would undermine United States ‘ credibility and damage our ability to pursue nuclear nonproliferation, a top national security priority.   This would obviously impact our efforts relative to Iran , North Korea , Syria and any other country which might see weapons of mass destruction as its salvation.  

We ask Congress to act now to pass S.2124.  World interests, American interests are at stake.  
Respectfully yours,
[signed by 20+ national diaspora organizations]